BAL Insights

Red Flags for HR: Lessons from ICAC’s Operation Tivoli

Written by Bill Pardy | Nov 16, 2026, 5:30:00 AM

On Friday 16 October 2026, BAL Director Bill Pardy presented to the HR Breakfast Club on lessons for HR from ICAC’s August 2026 report (Operation Tivoli) into the activities of a senior engineering director at the Illawarra Shoalhaven Local Health District (ISLHD).

ICAC found he had engaged in serious corrupt conduct and that the warning signs had passed through HR processes for years before his conduct was addressed.

Why this is an HR issue

HR has access to the recruitment file, the conflict-of-interest and secondary employment declarations, and the misconduct processes.

ICAC reported that 36% of mandatory reports of suspected corrupt conduct cite HR and staff management, more than any other function.

In Operation Tivoli, the first failure was in recruitment, and five of ICAC’s nine recommendations dealt with recruitment issues and conflicts of interest.

Operation Tivoli at a glance

A senior engineering director who was not an engineer won six public sector roles at four employers over 12 years, using false qualifications.

Date  Event 
2013

Wins the first of six roles using a false TAFE engineering diploma

Nov 2021  Appointed ISLHD Director, Engineering and Asset Management 
Mar 2022 Begins directing work to his sister’s business
Nov 2023 Starts undeclared secondary work for an ISLHD supplier
Jul 2024 ISLHD reports the matter to ICAC; he is suspended with pay
Sep 2024 Resigns from ISLHD; joins Transport for NSW, terminated by TfNSW Jan 2026
Aug 2026 ICAC finds serious corrupt conduct and recommends DPP consider charges

ISLHD paid $275,176 to his sister’s company and $613,247 to a former contact’s consultancy, almost all in orders under the $30,000 single-quote limit. A supplier also paid him $210,375 for undeclared secondary work.

Spotting the red flags

Recruitment. He ticked “Yes” to an Engineers Australia-accredited degree that his CV never mentioned. No one checked with the university or Engineers Australia. Referees included his sister (under her married name) and contacts reached solely via mobile numbers he supplied.

ICAC recommended HR unit should verify every qualification that influences selection directly with the issuing institution, and that referees be called through their organisation’s switchboard.

Conflicts of interest. His sister’s firm had never worked for ISLHD, and he ran its quotes himself, using personal email accounts. He declared a conflict only when a system check prompted it, claiming “no direct financial benefit”.

The correct test is whether a reasonable person might perceive bias. ICAC recommended asking about associations, not just conflicts, and keeping one register so that past declarations follow the person into different roles.

Secondary employment. He was paid by an ISLHD supplier whose work he approved. He had signed the Code of Conduct and completed every training module. Acknowledgment is not assurance: self-declaration needs a detection layer, such as periodic renewals, data checks and a safe route for colleagues to raise concerns.

Procurement patterns. Procurement is not HR’s job, but HR often hears the talk. Here, orders were clustered just under the $30,000 approval figure, and in one case a $133,750 project was split into six stages, and one person (the director) controlled every step of the purchasing cycle.

Asking the right questions

The aim is to turn a rumour or hunch into an answer, early. Practical prompts for HR:

Action Questions to ask 
Recruitment  Who verified this qualification, and with whom? How do we know the referee is who they say they are?
Declarations When was this last updated? Is there an association, if not a “conflict”? Is a vague declaration accepted or sent back for clarification?
Secondary employment  Is the other employer a supplier, client or competitor? Do the hours add up?
Patterns Is one person controlling every step? Why is everything just under a specific financial threshold?

At ISLHD, in December 2022, a prequalification check flagged the work sent to his sister’s business. By then $500,000 had already been paid. The lesson is: ask early, ask in every process, and test the answer against what has already been paid.

Knowing who to tell

Record what you saw, when, and the documents involved. Don’t confront the person: ICAC criticised a procedure that told staff to raise concerns with the colleague concerned. Instead, take concerns to a specialist area, such as governance, internal audit or a senior officer, and report externally where required. Reports should always bypass anyone who may be conflicted.

Confirm the obligations that apply to your organisation.

Why acting matters

The questions nobody asked cost ISLHD wasted money, an unqualified person managing critical hospital assets, an extensive ICAC investigation, damaged staff morale and a public report to Parliament. ICAC also recommended DPP advice on fraud offences.

Lessons for HR practitioners

Bill highlighted several employment law angles:

  • Manage and document every aspect of the situation.

  • Expect health issues to be raised. ‘Stress’ and ‘burnout’ were offered up as excuses by the director to explain the conduct, which ICAC rejected.

  • Keep any suspension under review and proportionate.

  • Resignation ends the employment, not the inquiry. Preserve records whether or not the employee leaves.

  • Be clear about access to work systems. Emails and texts decided this case, so access must stay within workplace surveillance and privacy laws.

  • Follow a fair process. False qualifications may justify dismissal, but a fair process is still required.

  • Put outside work and disclosure duties in employment contracts, not only in policies.

Need help?

For advice on HR and employment processes, or on a suspected integrity issue, contact BAL Lawyers on 02 6274 0999 or the author via bill.pardy@ballawyers.com.au.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Specific advice should be obtained before acting on any matter discussed.